Big Olaf's Ice Cream

Veg Options Ice Cream, Vegan Flavors

Limited vegan options chevron_right

★ 4.4 · $$ · Hours

DessertQuick BitesFamilies

Amenities: deck Outdoor Seating

lightbulb Popular tips:  "Try the vegan salted caramel soft serve" "Try the vegan salted caramel soft serve"
"Enjoy vegan lemon sorbet flavor"
"Cash only - bring cash for purchases"
"Vegan and gluten-free toppings available"
 

restaurant_menu Must-try:  ice cream, soft serve ice cream, soft serve ice cream — popular (×2)
soft serve ice cream — fan-favourite
soft serve — fan-favourite
sorbet — popular (×2)
 

thumb_up Praised for:  organic, variety, open late organic
variety
open late
good location
 

Big Olaf's Ice Cream is a well-established local ice cream parlor known for its organic and dairy-free soft serve options appealing to vegans and lactose-intolerant customers. The venue offers a variety of vegan flavors like salted caramel and lemon sorbet, along with traditional toppings and gluten-free choices, making it a popular seasonal spot. Recent reviews praise the diverse vegan selections and highlight its long-standing reputation and cash-only policy.

image

schedule

Hours

expand_more

Sunday 12-9:30 PM

Monday 12-9:30 PM

Tuesday Closed

Wednesday Closed

Thursday Closed

Friday 12-10:30 PM

Saturday 12-10:30 PM

location_on

Wharf St
Sag Harbor
NY 11963

directions Navigate on Google Maps

Spinach Rating

star 4.4

out of 5

Spinach Rating is created by analysing reviews and signals from the web.

info

External ratings

star 4.5 (68 reviews)

Read on Google Maps open_in_new

star 4 (1 reviews)

Read on HappyCow open_in_new

Vegan Friendliness

info

Limited vegan options

Vegan Options

some

Menu Clarity

poor labeling

Staff Knowledge

Basic Understanding

Warnings info

No warnings

Big Olaf's Ice Cream

Spinach Rating

Vegan Friendliness

More in Sag Harbor

Nikki's Not Dog Stand

Provisions

Sag Pizza

Estia's Little Kitchen

Buddhaberry