Skip to content

Photos via Google Maps

Buttermilk Bakeshop

Vegan Cakes, Cookies & Bars

Worth ordering: Cakenamed in 5 reviews

Ask about a custom vegan cake for a celebration; reviewers praised the cakes and the bakery's attention to requested details.

$$

Top tips

  • For party orders, the bakery can help coordinate vegan and gluten-free treats and clearly mark them.
  • If a bar assortment is unavailable online, call to ask about modifying the order.
All 3 tipsShow fewer
  • Consider a smaller slice when sharing the vegan vanilla cake; one reviewer found it dense and filling.

People mention

Cookie and vanilla cake.

Good for

The vibe: groups The vibe: families

Praised for attentive service and friendly service.

Good to know

  • Gluten-free options
  • Dessert, takeout

About

Buttermilk Bakeshop is a made-to-order dessert bakery known for custom celebration cakes, including vegan versions, alongside vegan cookies, brownies and bars. Reviews praise the responsive ordering process and clearly marked vegan and gluten-free party treats; delivery and pickup are available for special events.

Vegan menu

VEGAN
See all 3 dishes

Buttermilk Bakeshop · dine-in · 3 dishes

Not offered anymore, wrong price, or not vegan? Report

Photos

Photos from Google

Visit

Open the map

264 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Opening hours

Monday
Closed
Tuesday
11:00–18:00
Wednesday
11:00–18:00
Thursday
11:00–18:00
Friday
11:00–20:00
Saturday
11:00–20:00
Sunday
11:00–18:00

the food

4.9 out of 5. Spinach Rating

From recent reviews, out of 5.

  • Great food
Google Maps
4.7 714 reviews Read on Google Maps
HappyCow
2.0 1 reviews Read on HappyCow
How we rank

eating vegan

Outstanding for vegans

vegan options
Many · 5–10 dishes
menu
Clearly marked
staff
Knowledgeable
What the grades mean

nearby

More in Brooklyn

vegan food guide

brooklyn

The app is the full experience.

The live map, every ranking, and the dishes worth ordering.

  • free
  • no signup needed
The Spinach app: the Kraków map, each place with its rating and the dish worth ordering
in the app