Popular tips: "Try the Impossible meatball and Italian sausage hoagies for satisfying vegan subs."
"Try the Impossible meatball and Italian sausage hoagies for satisfying vegan subs."
"Enjoy outdoor seating during nice weather."
"Be aware that hoagie rolls contain trace amounts of milk whey, likely from shared equipment."
"Order the vegan butter brushed hoagie for enhanced flavor."
"Expect about a 15-minute wait for to-go orders."
Must-try: sandwich, sausage hoagie, hoagie
sandwich — popular (×5)
sausage hoagie — popular (×2)
hoagie — fan-favourite
meatball hoagie — fan-favourite
pizza — fan-favourite
Praised for: friendly service, cozy atmosphere, good value
friendly service
cozy atmosphere
good value
Fesslers Pizza is a longtime favorite known for its classic brick building ambiance and family-friendly vibe. The menu features pizza, hoagies, pasta, and burgers with a solid selection of vegan options like Impossible meatball and Italian sausage hoagies, along with vegan pizza substitutes. Outdoor seating and wheelchair accessibility add to the welcoming, casual experience, and recent reviewers praise the tasty plant-based hoagies and friendly service.