Frosty's Ice Cream
Ice Cream, Vegan Treats
Vegan options
Outstanding for vegans ★ 4.5 (575) · $$ · Ice Cream · Ice Cream, Dessert · Hours
Amenities: deck Outdoor Seating
Popular tips: "Try the vegan mint chocolate chip ice cream in a cone for a refreshing treat"
Must-try: ice cream, milkshake, mint chocolate chip
Praised for: friendly service
A classic ice cream shop loved by locals, Frosty's Ice Cream serves a variety of dairy-free and vegan frozen treats made with almond and oat milk. It has a nostalgic, family-friendly vibe with outdoor seating and an inviting atmosphere featuring a school bus and firetruck play area for kids. Customers praise both the vegan milkshakes and seasonal vegan flavors, alongside friendly, quick service and a cash-only policy with an onsite ATM available.
schedule
Hours
Sunday 12-9 PM
Monday 2-9 PM
Tuesday 2-9 PM
Wednesday 2-9 PM
Thursday 2-9 PM
Friday 2-9:30 PM
Saturday 12-9:30 PM
location_on
directions
Navigate on Google Maps
5500 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086
Vegan Friendliness
iOutstanding for vegans
A
- VEGAN OPTIONS Many · 5–10 dishes
- MENU Clearly marked
- STAFF Friendly
More in Lancaster
Two scores: Spinach Rating grades the food. Vegan Friendliness grades how easy it is to eat vegan here.
How we rank →The app is the full experience.
The live map, every ranking, and the dishes worth ordering — free, no signup.
Lancaster All Cities