Gaines Street Pies
Gaines Street Pies features a comic book-themed interior with a laid-back vibe and serves creative pizzas alongside craft beers in a casual setting. The venue is known for its standout vegan pizza called "The Temptation," praised for its rich and unique flavor combinations including hummus and balsamic vinegar. While the pizza quality is often highlighted, some reviews mention inconsistency in preparation and occasional overcooked or dry crusts, especially during busy times.
Vegan Friendliness
iVery vegan-friendly
- VEGAN OPTIONS Many · 5–10 dishes
- MENU Separate vegan menu
- STAFF Knowledgeable
- PROTEIN vegan sausage, tofu, roasted vegetables
Some users reported cross-contamination — worth asking about sauces before ordering.
Others mentioned inconsistent vegan claims on the menu.
More in Tallahassee
Two scores: Spinach Rating grades the food. Vegan Friendliness grades how easy it is to eat vegan here.
How we rank →The app is the full experience.
The live map, every ranking, and the dishes worth ordering — free, no signup.