Gotham Bagels
Gotham Bagels serves New York–style bagels with a notable selection of vegan cream cheese spreads like Toffuti and tofu-based options. The shop is known for its classic bagel sandwiches, including the vegan "Original V" loaded with savory toppings, and offers a casual, deli-style environment with busy service especially around breakfast and lunch. While bagel quality and size receive high praise, reviews often mention slow service and occasional order mix-ups, partially balanced by friendly staff on site.
Vegan Friendliness
iGood vegan options
- VEGAN OPTIONS Some · 3–5 dishes
- MENU Clearly marked
- STAFF Friendly
Some users reported cross-contamination — worth asking about sauces before ordering.
Others mentioned staff aren't always sure about ingredients.
A few noted vegan options aren't always available.
More in Madison
Two scores: Spinach Rating grades the food. Vegan Friendliness grades how easy it is to eat vegan here.
How we rank →The app is the full experience.
The live map, every ranking, and the dishes worth ordering — free, no signup.