Horatio's Homemade Ice Cream
Ice Cream, Coconut Sorbet
Vegan options
Poor vegan options ★ 3.3 (355) · $$ · Ice Cream · Dessert, Ice Cream, Sorbet · Hours
Popular tips: "Try the coconut-based Hawaiian flavor sorbet for a vegan treat"
Must-try: banana coconut, cinnamon apple pie, ice cream
Praised for: friendly service
Horatio's Homemade Ice Cream serves classic and seasonal ice cream flavors, with a small but appreciated vegan selection mainly focused on coconut-based sorbets. The shop is clean and family-friendly, featuring wheelchair accessibility and onsite dining. While the vegan options are limited, they offer a welcome treat for those seeking dairy-free choices alongside traditional ice cream.
schedule
Hours
Sunday 1-6 PM
Monday 12-7 PM
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 12-8 PM
Thursday 12-8 PM
Friday 12-8 PM
Saturday 12-8 PM
location_on
directions
Navigate on Google Maps
548 Mt Rushmore Rd, Custer, SD 57730
Vegan Friendliness
iPoor vegan options
E
- VEGAN OPTIONS Few · 2–3 dishes
- MENU Poorly marked
- STAFF Basic understanding
Some users reported cross-contamination — worth asking about sauces before ordering.
Others mentioned vegan options aren't always available.
More in Custer
Two scores: Spinach Rating grades the food. Vegan Friendliness grades how easy it is to eat vegan here.
How we rank →The app is the full experience.
The live map, every ranking, and the dishes worth ordering — free, no signup.
Custer All Cities