Popular tips: "Try the pumpernickel bagel with vegan Tofutti cream cheese"
"Try the pumpernickel bagel with vegan Tofutti cream cheese"
"Order the fresh squeezed orange juice for a balanced, not overly sweet drink"
"Use the plastic menu near the front of the line for easier reading"
"Enjoy dog-friendly outdoor seating when dining in"
"Be cautious in the busy parking lot during peak hours"
Must-try: bagel, orange juice, juice
bagel — popular (×2)
orange juice — popular (×2)
juice — popular (×2)
cheesecake — fan-favourite
cake — fan-favourite
Praised for: friendly service, cozy atmosphere
friendly service ×4
cozy atmosphere
Old New York Deli & Bakery Co serves classic New York style bagels with a notable vegan Tofutti cream cheese option, alongside a range of traditional deli items like breakfast tacos, sandwiches, and fresh baked goods. The venue is casual and comfortable with indoor and dog-friendly outdoor seating, wheelchair accessibility, and a New York themed ambiance that has remained consistent for decades. Visitors praise fresh squeezed orange juice and baked treats, though some dessert quality has shown inconsistency recently.
