Photos via Google Maps

The Brooklyn Firefly

Pizza, Vegan Pies & Calzones

Worth ordering: Pizzanamed in 21 reviews

Try the San Gennaro vegan pie; one reviewer added mushrooms and black olives and called it one of their best vegan pizzas.

4.2food Good vegan options

$$$

Directions

Website Call

Top tips

Ask about: mixed vegan claims

Ask about vegan cheese when ordering a regular pie, or choose from the vegan pizza menu.
Good to know: For delivery, confirm the vegan cheese amount when ordering; one frequent customer reported inconsistent portions.

All 4 tipsShow fewer

Consider a vegan calzone for a filling alternative to pizza.
Good to know: Check the kitchen's last seating time before arriving late; one Saturday visitor reported being turned away before the posted closing time.

People mention

Calzone and s'mores.

Good for

The vibe: dates The vibe: groups

Praised for lively atmosphere, beautiful interior and friendly service.

All 5 things people praiseShow fewer

Also praised for attentive service and good value.

Good to know

Outdoor seating
Lunch, dinner, takeout
Cards and mobile pay

About

The Brooklyn Firefly pairs a full bar and old-Brooklyn decor with vegan pizzas such as the San Gennaro, plus vegan calzones and build-your-own pies with vegan cheese. Reviews mention a roomy back dining area, patio seating, and occasional live music; diners have also reported uneven amounts of vegan cheese on delivery orders.