Popular tips: "Try the vegan jerk vegetables and cracked mushroom dishes for authentic flavors."
"Try the vegan jerk vegetables and cracked mushroom dishes for authentic flavors."
"The separate vegan menu makes it easy to find plant-based options."
"Allow extra time for orders during busy periods due to small staff."
"Ask staff to help select dishes that accommodate dietary needs."
"Enjoy sides like plantains, rice and peas, and potato salad that complement main dishes."
Must-try: jerk vegetables, plantain, tuna and grits
jerk vegetables — popular (×3)
plantain — popular (×2)
tuna and grits — popular (×2)
coconut macaroni — fan-favourite
fritter — fan-favourite
Praised for: friendly service
friendly service ×8
Thrifters On The Bay Cafe serves Caribbean cuisine with a focus on fresh, made-to-order dishes like vegan jerk vegetables and cracked mushrooms. The small cafe has a separate vegan menu on request, with offerings such as plantain stir-fry and curry vegetables, alongside traditional items like jerk chicken and tuna and grits. Friendly owner-operators share their Bahamian roots and take care to accommodate dietary needs despite being understaffed, creating a casual and welcoming dining experience with reasonable prices.